Some time ago I was taking part into design challange by James Shore. One of participants Par Oaz did his own analisys of all submitted solutions. He did a very nice job putting his effort on this, it was really interesting to check it out.
You can find an article by this link: http://agilitateur.azeau.com/post/2010/07/06/Architectural-Design-Challenge-by-James-Shore-:-a-review
Thanks for review, Par!